top of page

NEWS REPORTS 

POLICE REPORTS 

“Legislative office, hindi dapat sakop ng executive”: Kalinga SP voids Tabuk ordinance provisions transferring council secretariat to Mayor’s Office, urges restoration

Writer:  Mark Moises Calayan
Mark Moises Calayan
2 hours ago
4 min read

TABUK CITY, Kalinga — The Sangguniang Panlalawigan (SP) of Kalinga has declared invalid key provisions of Tabuk City Ordinance No. 035, Series of 2026, particularly those placing the Office of the Secretary to the Sangguniang Panlungsod, its personnel, and its records under the administrative and organizational structure of the Office of the City Mayor.


During its 39th Regular Session on November 10, 2026, the provincial board found the ordinance invalid in part, citing concerns that the arrangement could undermine the independence of the city council and improperly place legislative functions under the executive branch.


To address the issues, the provincial board urged the Tabuk City Council to amend its 2026 organizational structure and staffing pattern by restoring the Office of the Secretary, its personnel, and its archives functions under the Sangguniang Panlungsod.


The recommendations, presented by Board Member Christopher Dona-al, were carried by the provincial board following deliberations.


Based on the minutes of the meeting obtained by Guru Press Cordillera from the Sangguniang Panlalawigan Legislative staff, the provincial board exercised its review authority under Section 56(c) of Republic Act No. 7160, or the Local Government Code of 1991, which allows it to declare an ordinance invalid in whole or in part if it is inconsistent with law or beyond the powers of the local government unit.


Why the provisions were declared invalid


The provincial board pointed out that the Secretary to the Sangguniang Panlungsod performs legislative functions, including keeping records of council proceedings, maintaining ordinances and resolutions, and transmitting legislative measures.


Placing the office under the administrative structure of the Mayor’s Office could compromise its independence in serving the city council, particularly because the Secretary also transmits approved ordinances to the City Mayor for approval or veto and to the provincial board for review.


The board explained that the arrangement could affect the independence of the process because the office handles legislative records and documents involving measures that may be subject to the Mayor’s veto.


The provincial board also questioned the transfer of the office’s 11 positions to the Mayor’s Office.


In its legal discussion under Ground 3, the board explained that the 10 support positions are employees of the Sangguniang Panlungsod appointed by the Vice Mayor, who serves as its presiding officer.


Citing the Tabuk City Charter, the Local Government Code, and the Supreme Court ruling in Atienza v. Villarosa, the board noted that transferring these positions to the Mayor’s Office would place their appointment and funding under the executive branch, despite these being functions belonging to the presiding officer of the legislative body.


It likewise found that the ordinance improperly assigned the preservation, custody, and disposition of city records and local archives to the City Public Information Office, functions that the law assigns to the Secretary to the Sangguniang Panlungsod.


The provincial board also addressed the ordinance’s provision stating that the Secretary would continue performing duties required by law.


It explained that this provision does not remove the administrative consequences of placing the office under the Mayor because an organizational structure establishes reporting arrangements, administrative accountability, and lines of supervision.


What Tabuk City should do


The provincial board emphasized that while the City Government has the authority to establish its organizational structure, it must exercise this power consistently with existing laws and government regulations.


During the deliberations, Board Member Camilo Lammawin suggested that the ordinance be declared invalid only in part rather than in its entirety, allowing the city to implement provisions not covered by the legal concerns.


He also stressed that the Secretary’s Office should remain under the Sangguniang Panlungsod and separate from the organizational structure of the Mayor’s Office, consistent with the division between the executive and legislative branches.


The board clarified that its action does not affect the City Mayor’s authority under the Tabuk City Charter to appoint the Secretary to the Sangguniang Panlungsod, subject to the concurrence of the majority of the city council members.


It also upheld other provisions of the ordinance that it found consistent with law, including the transfer of the Procurement Management Division and the provision maintaining the Secretary’s duties under existing laws. Under the ordinance’s separability clause, the remaining valid provisions continue to take effect.


The provincial board further recommended supporting proposed national legislation seeking to authorize the City Vice Mayor to appoint the Secretary to the Sangguniang Panlungsod, in line with the arrangement in other cities.


The board’s findings did not cover other observations concerning the ordinance, including the need to correct the wording of Section 15, or the repealing clause, which referred to ordinances both in conflict with and consistent with the new measure.


It also discussed the city’s personnel services limit and the requirements for posting and publication before the ordinance takes effect. During the session, City Assistant Budget Officer Yeahsylyn Ledda said the city’s personnel services computation for 2027 remained within the allowable limit, while funding for succeeding years would depend on the city government’s management.


Background: Opposition to the proposed reorganization


The issue had earlier drawn public attention when Tabuk City Councilor Atty. Errol B. Comafay Jr. publicly opposed the proposed reorganization placing the Office of the Secretary to the Sangguniang Panlungsod under the Mayor.


In a September 14, 2026 report of Guru Press Cordillera, Comafay warned that the proposed arrangement could weaken the separation of powers and checks and balances in the city government.


“The Secretary to the Sangguniang Panlungsod should not be under the Mayor,” Comafay said, stressing that the office serves as the legislative secretariat of the City Council and should remain under its control and supervision.


“If the Mayor has control and supervision over the Secretary to the Sanggunian, the Secretary will follow the Mayor, not the Sanggunian,” he added.


The report said the proposed ordinance was scheduled for deliberation during the Sangguniang Panlungsod plenary session on September 15, 2026.


Comafay’s opposition centered on concerns that placing the legislative secretariat under the Mayor could compromise its independence and affect the city council’s ability to perform its legislative and oversight functions.


The proposed reorganization was later enacted as City Ordinance No. 035, Series of 2026, which subsequently underwent review by the Kalinga Sangguniang Panlalawigan.


The provincial board’s November 10 action partially invalidated the measure, particularly the provisions concerning the administrative placement of the legislative secretariat, its personnel, and its records.

Related Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page